Skip to content

150Nd activation decay chain incorrectly handled. #127

Open

Description

@pkienzle

The 150Nd activation chain is not handled correctly:

150Nd (n,y) 151Nd (β⁻ 12m) 151Pm (β⁻ 28.4h) 151Sm (β⁻ 90y) 151Eu

The 151Pm halflife is instead treated as if it were 151Nd:

150Nd (n,y) 151Nd (β⁻ 12m) 151Pm (β⁻ 12m) 151Sm (β⁻ 90y) 151Eu

Use the multistage Bateman equation (wikipedia) to check the 151Pm activation levels and compare it to the two-stage calculation shown below.

With 10 g of Nd at natural abundance exposed for 10 h it appears that decay time will be dominated by 147Pm, so even an underestimate of the intermediate 151Pm levels should not be too concerning.


Activation of Nd after 10 hrs at 1.00e+8 n/cm2/s

Estimated activation only. All samples must be evaluated by NIST Health Physics to determine if and how the sample can be removed from the NCNR.

Sample in beam: 10.000 g of Nd
Time to decay below 5.0000e-4 μCi is 11.5 yrs.

Isotope reaction daughter halflife 0 hr 1 hr 24 hr 15 days 7.8 y
Nd-146 act Nd-147t 10.98 d 6.9608e-1 6.9425e-1 6.5350e-1 2.7003e-1 6.1453e-79
Nd-146 b Pm-147 2.6234 y 1.0535e-4 1.2630e-4 5.9308e-4 4.9559e-3 1.0423e-3
Nd-148 act Nd-149t 1.728 h 1.5441e+1 1.0339e+1 1.0179e-3 2.9792e-62 0.0000e+0
Nd-148 b Pm-149 53.08 h 1.4703e+0 1.6162e+0 1.4545e+0 1.8080e-2 0.0000e+0
Nd-150 act Nd-151t 12.44 m 7.2916e+0 2.5758e-1 1.0397e-34 0.0000e+0 0.0000e+0
Nd-150 b Pm-151 28.40 h 1.5371e+0 1.5505e+0 8.8553e-1 2.4306e-4 0.0000e+0
Nd-150 b Sm-151 94.6 y 5.9131e-5 5.9502e-5 5.9515e-5 5.9498e-5 5.6212e-5
Total 2.6437e+1 1.4458e+1 2.9952e+0 2.9337e-1 1.0986e-3

b reaction activity is slightly underestimated; it does not include decay of transients after removal from beam.


Activity

  1. pkienzle commented on Jun 4, 2026

    @pkienzle
    CollaboratorAuthor

    I verified that the activity in 151Pr at t=0 translates into activity in 151Sm scaled by the ratio of the half-lives (29,180) after 284 hrs (10 half-lives for 99.9% decay). The 151Nd activity is lost.

    This may be the incorrect calculation. Because the half life of 151Nd was used in calculating the initial 151Sm activity, it may be that all of the activity stored in the 151Pr transient has already been added into 151Sm at t=0. It may be more correct to use the 151Nd activity and half-life when calculating the delayed beta increase. Even better, we could subtract the 151Pr scaled activity from 151Sm at t=0, and let it build up during post-irradiation decay.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions